Clarence Eugene Butterfield, 57, was convicted today of murdering his daughter and keeping her body in a freezer in his recreational vehicle, according to a news release from the Orange County district attorney’s office.
Butterfield, formerly of San Clemente, was found guilty of one felony count of special circumstances murder during the commission of torture and mayhem and one felony count of assault with a firearm.
Butterfield faces life in prison without the possibility of parole at his sentencing Oct. 8.
In December 2006, Butterfield tortured his 21-year-old daughter, Rebekah Butterfield, by repeatedly shooting her in body parts that would not cause fatal injuries, according to the release. Clarence Butterfield tied his naked daughter’s ankles together and her hands behind her back and stuffed her in the RV’s freezer while she was alive. Rebekah Butterfield suffocated to death in the air-tight freezer.
In September 2008, Clarence Butterfield was arrested on an unrelated case in Orange County, and was sent to Nevada on an unrelated criminal warrant. His RV, which was left in the alley of an acquaintance’s business, was towed.
While cleaning the RV on Oct. 28, 2008, employees from AC Towing Inc. in San Clemente, discovered the woman’s body in the freezer. The towing company contacted the Orange County Sheriff’s Department. The body was badly decomposed and wrapped in several layers of plastic.
The investigation revealed that Clarence Butterfield also tortured his daughter in the months leading up to the murder, including stabbing her in the thigh in 2004 and shooting her in the foot several months earlier. These crimes went unreported.
Clarence Butterfield, who was still in custody in Las Vegas when his daughter’s body was discovered, was charged Oct. 30, 2008, with the murder of Rebekah Butterfield. The defendant was brought back to Orange County on April 14, 2009, to face charges. He was indicted on the charges Dec. 8, 2009.
During the trial, evidence was presented that Butterfield had a history of violence against his ex-wife and had repeatedly tortured her including beating, binding and keeping her in closets. The defendant’s son testified that he had witnessed some of the torture of his mother. Butterfield testified that he did not murder his daughter, but instead found her dead in the trailer and kept her body in the freezer because he thought no one would believe him.
Senior Deputy Dist. Atty. Ebrahim Baytieh of the Homicide Unit is prosecuting this case.